Main Street America

📌 Overview

Main Street America Insurance (founded 1923) provides personal and commercial insurance via independent agents across the U.S. Founded as National Grange Mutual Insurance Company in New Hampshire, it writes over $1.1 billion in annual premiums and merged with American Family Insurance in 2018.

Founded: March 28, 1923
Headquarters: Jacksonville, FL & Keene, NH
Employees: ~501–1,000 (LinkedIn); some sources suggest ~585

Why Main Street America?

• Century‑long heritage & stability: Started in 1923, a trusted local partner now with a strong national presence

• Financial strength: A.M. Best rating “A” (Excellent), Stable outlook; issuer credit rating “a+”

• Independent‑agent focus: Strong commitment to agent relationships and local service

• Backed by a powerful group: Part of American Family Insurance (13th-largest U.S. P/C group) since 2018

Products

• Personal lines: Auto, Homeowners, Farm & Ranch

• Commercial lines: Business Owners, General Liability, Workers’ Comp, Umbrella, Surety Bonds, Fidelity Bonds

• Excess & Surplus lines: Specialized E&S products in select states

Why Buy Through Insurox

• Tailored local expertise: Insurox agents can match businesses and families with precise coverage.

• Seamless excellence: Combine Main Street’s financial strength and independence with Insurox’s responsiveness.

• Simplified claims & billing: Insurox’s support expedites filing and payment, reducing hassle.

📝 Get a Quote Today

📍 No matter where you live, we can help.
👉 Click below to compare Workers’ Compensation insurance quotes, including Main Street America.

Get Your Free Main Street America Insurance Quote Now

• How to File a Claim

  1. Contact your Insurox agent — we’ll guide you through the process.

  2. Alternatively, go to Main Street’s website and select “Report a Claim”.

  3. Provide details (incident, policy, photos, documentation).

  4. Your agent tracks progress and keeps you informed.

• How to Pay

  • Online: Via Main Street’s “Make a Payment” portal or through Insurox.

  • Agent‑assisted: Pay by phone or coordinate billing options with your Insurox agent.

  • Other options: Mailing a check or setting up automatic drafts—Insurox can assist setup.